Spirit Daily


Medjugorje Apparition Are Divisive, Bishop Warns

From CW News

First story

Jul. 04 (CWNews.com) - The Catholic bishop whose diocese includes the town of Medjugorje has warned that "something similar to a schism" has arisen at the parish church where apparitions of the Virgin Mary are alleged to take place.

In a homily delivered in Medjugorje on the feast of Corpus Christi, Bishop Ratko Peric of Mostar-Duvno, in Bosnia-Herzegovina, said that both he and his predecessor have expressed severe misgivings about the reported apparitions. He added that both Pope John Paul II (bio - news) and Pope Benedict XVI (bio - news) backed the judgments of the local bishops.

In his homily Bishop Peric explained that-- "while recognizing the Holy Father's right to give a final decision" on the validity of the reported apparitions-- he doubted their validity. He recalled that when he discussed the reports from Medjugorje with Vatican officials, including then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger at the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, they shared his incredulity.

"They particularly do not seem to be authentic," the bishop observed, "when it is known before that these so-called 'apparitions' will occur." Bishop Peric cited the schedule that the Medjugorje seers have provided, listing the times and places at which they claim the next visits by the Mother of God will occur. Thousands of messages from Mary are now claimed, and the bishop observed that "the flood of so-called apparitions, messages, secrets, and signs do not strengthen the faith, but rather further convince us that in all of this there is nothing neither authentic nor established as truthful."

The first reported appearances of the Virgin at Medjugorje occurred just over 25 years ago. During the 1980s, thousands of Catholic flocked to the little town, with many reporting profound spiritual experiences. These pilgrimages were eventually slowed by the violent bloodshed that tore through the region in the 1990s and by the increasingly public skepticism of the hierarchy.

Bishop Peric reminded his people of the restrictions that he has imposed on activities in Medjugorje. The parish church is not formally a "shrine," he said, and should not be characterized as such. Pilgrimages to the church are discouraged. Priests there are "not authorized to express their private views contrary to the official position of the Church on the so-called 'apparitions' and 'messages,' during celebrations of the sacraments, nor during other common acts of piety, nor in the Catholic media."

The bishops urged the "seers" of Medjugorje to "demonstrate ecclesiastical obedience and to cease with these public manifestations and messages in this parish."

Some of the Franciscan priests assigned to the Medjugorje parish, he said, have been expelled from their order because of their refusal to accept Church authority. "They have not only been illegally active in these parishes, but they have also administered the sacraments profanely, while others invalidly," he said. As Bishop of Mostar-Duvno, he said, he felt obliged to warn the faithful "who invalidly confess their sins to these priests and participate in sacrilegious liturgies."


Joseph Ratzinger, Pope Benedict XVI

By Debbie Thompson & Michael K. Jones


Second story

Joseph Ratzinger, now known as Pope Benedict XVI, was born of German decent in 1927. He entered into a seminary at a young age but was delayed because of World War II. However, in 1945 he re-entered, and was ordained a priest a few years later. He then received his doctrine in theology at age 30 and became known for being one of the top theologians in the Vatican.

Ratzinger had served over 20 years as John Paul II's Chief Theological Advisor, and in 1977 became cardinal by Pope Paul VI. April 19, 2005 Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger became the 265th pope, and being the first German pope in centuries. He is known now as Pope Benedict XVI, a name of Holy origin. Benedict is Latin for "Blessing."

Pope Benedict XVI, a conservative, has outlined his goals and made clear his pontificate would closely follow his predecessor Pope John Paul II. Benedict has said his primary task would be to work to reunify all Christians and that sentiment alone was not enough. "Concrete acts that enter souls and move consciences are needed," he said. His plans also include continuing an open and sincere dialogue with other religions.

Benedict, who is now 78, is the oldest elected pope and will skillfully lead the church through John Paul II's legacy.

Brief History

On November 25, 1981 John Paul II nominated Ratzinger as Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith; President of the Biblical Commission and of the Pontifical International Theological Commission.

The office of the Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith promotes and safeguards the Church's doctrine and defends Christian traditions in danger of new unacceptable doctrines."

New doctrine often time seems rooted in the concept of Modernism. Modernism is abhorrent to many traditionalists in the Church as it promotes a more secular role. The secular role lessens the dogma of the Church which stands as a foundation of the Doctrine of the Faith.

Traditionalists who see grave attempts to remodel the Church into a new age of Modernism can rest easy for now. The Dogma of the Church is protected as Pope Benedict XVI has a heart for tradition.

The Election

It was late in the first full day of a conclave when white smoke streamed from a chimney of the Sistine Chapel; shortly before 6 p.m. an estimated crowd of 20,000 in St. Peter's Square cheered. Within minutes, bells pealed in confirmation that a new Pope had been elected. About an hour later, Cardinal Jorge Arturo Medina Estevez of Chile heralded the news with the traditional Latin words "Habemus papam" -- "We have a pope."

Pope Benedict XVI emerged and spoke to those gathered in wait. "Dear brothers and sisters, after the great Pope John Paul II, the cardinals have elected me, a simple, humble worker in the Lord's vineyard," the new pontiff said, raising his arms to respond to the applause. "The fact that the Lord can work and act even with insufficient means consoles me, and above all, I entrust myself to your prayers."

Ratzinger & Medjugorje

Though Cardinals, Bishops, priests, religious and faithful are divided over the belief of the Marian apparition site of Medjugorje there is nothing to indicate any changes in the future with newly elected Benedict XVI. We know that John Paul II had a favorable response to Medjugorje, even though the first Commission set up to investigate Medjugorje did not.

On March 25, 1985, a letter from local Bishop Pavlo Zanic ordered the Medjugorje parish priests to cancel all pilgrimages, and to forbid the 6 young visionaries from gathering in the church or adjacent area. The gatherings were then transposed to the parish residence. In September 1987, Zanic forbid the apparition gatherings in the parish hall as well. Towards the end of 1986, Zanic traveled to Rome to inform the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith of his views on Medjugorje, but Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, Prefect of the Congregation, transferred decisional authority to the Yugoslav Bishops' Conference.

A second Commission was appointed when it was discovered that the first was tainted. The first Commission was a group who had publicly announced they did not believe prior to their appointment to the Medjugorje Commission. However, due to political events the second Commission did not complete its findings. The question remains if the first Commission's findings therefore are the order of the day, or because the second Commission was disbanded without a finding, if the faithful have the right to continue to worship in Medjugorje.

Bishop Zanic for the rest of his life would remain an outspoken opponent of the Medjugorje apparitions. In fact he was so outspoken that Ratzinger forwarded a letter to the Yugoslav Bishops' Conference. The Conference of Bishops informed Zanic that Ratzinger said to stop his negative media blitz against the apparitions. Bishop Zanic did not respond to the Cardinal Ratzingers request and he continued to strongly stand opposed.

As the reader can see here, Medjugorje remains a controversial subject. For some it is a haven of Holy Ground and for others it is an embarrassment surrounded in disbelief. Regardless of the divisions, it does appear that Pope Benedict XVI views on Medjugorje are positive and open minded as were John Paul's.

If you would like to write Debbie Thompson, she welcomes your comments:
Debbie Thompson

If you would like to write Medjugorje USA

Return to Spiritdaily.com

Return to archive page

You are at www.spiritdaily.org